Isaac McGarvey standing outdoors
Isaac McGarvey, pictured outdoors in a family photograph.
Overview

Family, Work, and Community Life

Isaac McGarvey’s story is deeply connected to the broader McGarvey family history in southern Ohio. He was born in 1869 into a large Appalachian family headed by Hamilton McGarvey and Catherine Myers, part of a generation that lived through the economic and social transformation of the Ohio River Valley during the late nineteenth century. Isaac grew up alongside brothers and sisters in a working-class household shaped by labor, migration, and family continuity. Hamilton McGarvey family section

During the late 1880s and early 1890s, Isaac became part of the movement into the growing industrial town of Wellston, Ohio. Founded in 1873 as a railroad and furnace community, Wellston rapidly expanded through coal mining, iron furnaces, brick manufacturing, and related industries. Like many working families drawn to Jackson County’s industrial opportunities, Isaac and Mary Patton McGarvey established themselves within this developing town and created the McGarvey family line that would remain connected to Wellston for generations.

The C Street home became the center of that family history. Census records and later family memory place Isaac, Mary, their children, grandchildren, and later descendants within the same household over multiple decades. Through Isaac, the McGarvey family became firmly rooted in Wellston’s industrial and community life, transforming from a migrating Appalachian family into a multigenerational Wellston household. 1900 census 1930 census 503 C Street house

The known children of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey include Clarence, Daniel, William, Susan Anna, Mary Ellen, Margaret, and Charles Leo McGarvey. children

Early Life

Isaac McGarvey in Context

Isaac McGarvey was born into a large working-class family rooted in the Ohio River Valley during the years following the Civil War. He was the son of Hamilton McGarvey and Catherine Myers McGarvey and grew up in a household shaped by labor, migration, and strong family ties. Census records from the 1870s and 1880s place the family in Lawrence County, Ohio, where Isaac spent his childhood alongside several brothers and sisters. Hamilton family section

Isaac grew up with three younger brothers, Samuel, William J., and Edward McGarvey, along with two younger sisters, Mary Ann and Rose. Together, the children formed part of a growing Appalachian Ohio family that would eventually spread into industrial towns across southern Ohio and West Virginia. Isaac would later become the family member most closely associated with Wellston, where he established the C Street household that anchored the McGarvey family in Jackson County for multiple generations.

Isaac came of age during the rapid industrial growth of southern Ohio. Coal mining, furnaces, railroads, and small manufacturing communities transformed towns such as Wellston into centers of working-class opportunity. Like many families in the region, the McGarveys appear to have followed that economic movement into Jackson County and Wellston during the late nineteenth century.

Census records, birth records, marriage records, and later family documents place Isaac within a stable household centered on his marriage to Mary Patton McGarvey and the raising of their children. Rather than focusing on public prominence, Isaac’s surviving story is grounded in everyday life: work, home ownership, family continuity, and community ties in Wellston, Ohio.

Wellston became the central setting for much of the McGarvey family history. The records connected to Isaac’s children repeatedly place the family in Jackson County and at the family home on C Street, establishing the community itself as an important part of the narrative. Charles Leo birth certificate 1900 census

Marriage

Marriage to Mary Patton

Portrait crop of Mary Patton McGarvey
Mary Patton McGarvey, later in life.

Isaac McGarvey married Mary Patton in Lawrence County, Ohio, in December 1888. The marriage record is especially important because it places Isaac, Mary, and Isaac’s father, Hamilton McGarvey, in the same legal document. marriage record

1888 marriage certificate for Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton
Marriage record for Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton, Lawrence County, Ohio, December 1888.

Hamilton McGarvey appears as the sworn informant and gives consent for Isaac’s marriage. The record also notes that written consent from Mary Patton’s mother was on file, which fits the young ages of both Isaac and Mary at the time. Isaac was about nineteen, while Mary was likely about fifteen.

Family Home

The McGarvey House on C Street

Front view of 503 C Street McGarvey house
503 C Street, photographed by John McGarvey in 2004.
Side view of 503 C Street McGarvey house
Side view of the C Street house.

One of Isaac McGarvey’s most important family legacies was the house at 503 C Street in Wellston. City property records state that the home was built in 1890. Family tradition holds that Isaac had the house built, though the earliest document currently connecting Isaac’s household to the C Street property is the 1900 United States Census. 1900 census

The C Street home became a multigenerational McGarvey anchor. Isaac lived there, his son Charles Leo McGarvey later purchased the house from him, and Fred McGarvey also lived there. In that sense, the house is not just a residence. It represents family continuity, stability, and the movement of the McGarvey family from Isaac’s generation into the twentieth century.

Later records continue to connect the family to the address, including William “Beezer” McGarvey’s World War I service record, which lists him at 503 W. C Street in Wellston. WWI service record The 2004 photographs preserve the appearance of the home long after it had served as a McGarvey family residence. house photographs

Isaac and Mary Patton McGarvey’s legacy also continued through their children. Their family included Clarence, Daniel, William “Beezer,” Susan Anna, Mary Ellen, Margaret, and Charles Leo McGarvey. Some children died young, while others carried the family story into adulthood through work, marriage, military service, and later generations. Together, their lives show how the McGarvey family remained rooted in Wellston while also extending beyond it.

Family

Children of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey

These cards summarize each known child of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey. Source documents for births, deaths, census records, photographs, and other evidence are now collected in the document gallery.

Hover to Identify - Left to right: Mary Ellen McGarvey, Susan “Sue” McGarvey, William “Beezer” McGarvey, Margaret McGarvey, and Charles Leo McGarvey.
Child Profile

Clarence McGarvey

Death record for Clarence McGarvey in Jackson County, Ohio
Clarence McGarvey’s 1899 death record from Jackson County, Ohio.

Born: July 7, 1890, Lawrence County, Ohio

Died: February 26, 1899, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Cause of Death: Clarence was killed as a child in tragic accident with a cricket bat which resulted in an infection.

Clarence was one of the earliest known children of Isaac and Mary Patton McGarvey. His short life is documented by both a birth record and a death record.

Related records: birth record death record

Child Profile

Daniel McGarvey

Grave marker for Daniel McGarvey, 1893 to 1914
Grave Marker for Daniel McGarvey 1893 to 1914.

Born: February 1893, Ohio, based on the 1900 census

Died: July 5, 1914, Jackson County, Ohio

Cause of Death: Daniel pershied in a fire.

Daniel appears in the family timeline between Clarence and William. His death index helps explain why he does not appear later in Isaac and Mary’s household.

Related records: 1900 census death index

Child Profile

William “Beezer” McGarvey

Portrait crop of William “Beezer” McGarvey
William “Beezer” McGarvey, cropped from a family photograph.

Born: October 28, 1896, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Died: December 26, 1975, Ross County, Ohio

Nickname:Beezer McGarvey

Spouse: Mabel Mowery, 1901 to 1971, married September 20, 1920, in Jackson County, Ohio; later married Nellie Levis, 1903 to 1983, on October 19, 1940

Occupation: Laborer in pipe foundry

Children: Catherine McGarvey, 1922 to 1965; Clarence Eugene McGarvey, 1923 to 1968; Helen Jean McGarvey, 1925 to 1998

William, known in family references as “Beezer,” was one of Isaac and Mary’s sons who lived into adulthood. His records connect him to Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio, where the McGarvey family lived across several census years. He also served as a private in the U.S. Army during World War I.

World War I gravestone for William McGarvey
William McGarvey’s World War I gravestone, marking him as a private in the U.S. Army.

Related records: birth index 1900 census 1910 census WWI service record

Child Profile

Susan Anna McGarvey

Portrait crop of Susan Anna McGarvey
Susan Anna McGarvey, cropped from a family photograph.

Born: November 2, 1899, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Died: March 11, 1981, Port Charlotte, Charlotte County, Florida

Spouse:Willam Henry Ehrenfeld (1890-1958) married May 26,1917.

Occupation:Homemaker

Children: William Ehrenfeld (1918-1994), Ray Douglas Ehrenfeld (1920-), Clyde Franklin Ehrenfeld (1928-1980), Susan Ehrenfeld (1934-1956)

Susan Anna McGarvey was one of Isaac and Mary’s daughters. A family photograph may show her with Mary Patton McGarvey as a young woman.

Related records: birth index photo with Mary

Child Profile

Mary Ellen McGarvey

Born: February 6, 1903, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Died: June 5, 1978, Gallia County, Ohio

Nickname: Chow Mama - (Fred McGarvey as a young child couldn't say Charle's mama)

Spouse:Linn Bryan (1880-1946) married on Jan 30, 1926

Children: Charles Bryan (1931-2013)

Mary Ellen McGarvey extends the documented child timeline of Isaac and Mary into the early twentieth century.

Related records: birth index 1910 census

Child Profile

Margaret McGarvey

Born: March 2, 1907, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Died: February 6, 1984, Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio

Nickname: Aunt Cookie

Spouse: George Scarborough (1907-1959) married on March 19, 1927 in Jackson Ohio.

Children: Mary Elvira Scarborough (1928-2011), Jack Scarborough(1929-1995)

Margaret was one of Isaac and Mary’s younger children and appears in later household records.

Related records: birth index 1910 census 1920 census

Child Profile

Charles Leo McGarvey

Born: July 17, 1913, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Died: 1997

Spouse: Mary Ann Hughes (1916-2007)

Occupation: Factory manager / industrial work, details to refine

Children: Charles Frederick McGarvey (1934-Present)/p>

Charles Leo McGarvey is the youngest known child in this group and connects Isaac’s family page to the separate Charles Leo McGarvey athletic and career page.

Related records: birth certificate 1940 census

Work and Community

Isaac McGarvey as a Furnace Man

Historic birdseye view of Wellston, Ohio from the furnace stack
Historic birdseye view of Wellston, Ohio from the furnace stack.
Historic aerial view of downtown Wellston, Ohio
Historic aerial view of downtown Wellston, showing the industrial and neighborhood landscape that shaped the McGarvey family’s world.

Wellston itself was a young industrial town when Isaac McGarvey came of age. Founded in 1873 on land owned by Harvey Wells, the community rapidly developed around coal mining, furnaces, railroads, and iron production. By the 1880s and 1890s, Wellston had become one of the important industrial communities of southeastern Ohio, attracting working families seeking opportunity in the growing furnace economy. Wellston history

Isaac’s move into Wellston in the late 1880s or early 1890s placed him directly inside that industrial world. Census records identify him with labor-oriented occupations tied to Wellston’s furnace and factory economy, where furnaces, railroads, brick plants, and foundries shaped everyday life for working-class families. By 1900, Isaac and Mary Patton McGarvey had established their household on C Street in Wellston. 1900 census 1910 census 1920 census

Family memory preserved by Fred McGarvey described Isaac, known throughout the family as “Ike,” as a man with limited formal education but remarkable mechanical ability. According to Fred, Ike “could fix anything.” When machinery broke down at the factory, workers and supervisors would reportedly come to the McGarvey home on C Street looking for Ike’s help. These stories present Isaac not simply as a laborer, but as a skilled workingman whose practical knowledge earned respect within the community.

That reputation fits the industrial culture of Wellston during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Furnace communities depended heavily on experienced workers who understood machinery, repairs, furnaces, and industrial systems through years of practical experience rather than formal schooling. Isaac’s story reflects that tradition of mechanical skill, reliability, and community reputation among working-class Ohio families.

The census records show Isaac’s work life unfolding across several decades of Wellston’s industrial economy. In 1900, he is listed as a furnace worker, placing him directly in the furnace world that shaped the town. By 1910 and 1920, the records continue to connect him to furnace and industrial labor, suggesting long-term experience rather than temporary employment. By 1930, Isaac is recorded as a laborer in an ore mill or furnace-related setting, while also owning a home valued at about $1,000. 1900 census 1910 census 1920 census 1930 census

The C Street house became closely tied to that identity. Family members remembered the home not only as a residence, but as the place where neighbors and factory workers sought out Ike’s expertise when something needed repaired. In that sense, the house represented both family continuity and Isaac’s role within the working life of Wellston.

Isaac McGarvey with his granddaughter Susan Ehrenfeld
Isaac “Ike” McGarvey in later life with his granddaughter Susan Ehrenfeld.
Angled side view of 503 C Street McGarvey house in Wellston, Ohio
Another view of the McGarvey home on C Street, photographed by John McGarvey in 2004.
End of Life

Later Years, Death, and Burial

Mary Patton McGarvey died on May 15, 1931, closing more than four decades of marriage and family life with Isaac. Mary death index

Isaac spent his final decade at the McGarvey home on C Street in Wellston. The 1930 census shows Isaac and Mary still living there with family, while the 1940 census places Isaac in the household of his son Charles Leo McGarvey, Charles’s wife Mary Ann, and their son Freddie. Together, these records show that the C Street house remained a multigenerational family home at the end of Isaac’s life. 1930 census 1940 census

Isaac and Mary McGarvey gravestone
Gravestone of Isaac McGarvey (1869-1941) and Mary Patton McGarvey (1873-1931).

Isaac was buried in Ridgewood Cemetery in Wellston alongside members of his family. His burial location reflects the family’s long connection to the community and to Jackson County itself. The shared gravestone with Mary Patton McGarvey visually represents the family household that formed the center of Isaac’s life story. gravestone

Modern cemetery records and memorial documentation continue to preserve Isaac’s memory. The Find a Grave memorial for Isaac McGarvey connects his burial to Ridgewood Cemetery and links him with Mary Patton McGarvey and other family members documented throughout this page. Find a Grave

Documents

Documents and Records

This section is for census records, vital records, photographs, local history sources, and other materials that help document Isaac McGarvey’s life and family context.

Birth Index

William “Beezer” McGarvey Birth Index, 1896

Birth index for William McGarvey
Birth index for William McGarvey, born October 28, 1896.

Identifies William McGarvey as the son of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton.

View

Transcript

William McGarvey, male, white, born October 28, 1896, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patton.

Why this matters

This record confirms William’s birth date, birthplace, and parentage.

Birth Index

Susan Anna McGarvey Birth Index, 1899

Birth index for Susan Anna McGarvey
Birth index for Susan McGarvey, born November 2, 1899.

Identifies Susan McGarvey as a daughter of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton.

View

Transcript

Susan McGarvey, female, white, born November 2, 1899, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Jap/Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patten.

Why this matters

This record confirms Susan Anna’s birth and preserves the variant father-name reading in the index.

Military Record

William McGarvey World War I Service Record

World War I service record entry for William McGarvey of Wellston, Ohio
World War I service entry for William McGarvey of Wellston, Ohio.

Person: William McGarvey

Record type: World War I service record

Date: 1918

Residence: 503 W. C Street, Wellston, Ohio

Unit: 158th Depot Brigade

Rank: Private

View

Transcript

McGarvey, William. 3854499. White. 503 W. C St., Wellston, O. N.A. Jackson, O. September 3, 1918. Born Wellston, O., August 26, 1896. 158 Depot Brig to discharge. Private. Honorably discharged December 8, 1918.

Why this matters

This record documents William “Beezer” McGarvey’s World War I service and connects him directly to Wellston, Ohio. It also preserves an alternate birth date of August 26, 1896, which should be compared against his Ohio birth index date of October 28, 1896.

Census Record

1900 United States Census, Isaac McGarvey Household

1900 United States Census for Isaac McGarvey household
1900 census page showing Isaac McGarvey’s household in Wellston, Ohio.

Documents Isaac, Mary, and their children near the turn of the twentieth century.

Household: Isaac McGarvey

Record type: Federal census

Date: June 14, 1900

Place: C Street, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Importance: Earliest known record placing Isaac McGarvey’s household at the C Street home

View

Transcript

Isaac McGarvey household, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Household includes Isaac, Mary, and children including Clarence, William, and Susan Anna.

Why this matters

The 1900 census anchors Isaac’s household, children, residence, and occupational context.

Birth Index

Mary Ellen McGarvey Birth Index, 1903

Birth index for Mary Ellen McGarvey
Birth index for Mary Ellen McGarvey, born February 6, 1903.

Identifies Mary Ellen McGarvey as a daughter of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton.

View

Transcript

Mary Ellen McGarvey, female, white, born February 6, 1903, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patton.

Why this matters

This record documents one of Isaac and Mary’s daughters and extends the child timeline into the early 1900s.

Birth Index

Margaret McGarvey Birth Index, 1907

Birth index for Margaret McGarvey
Birth index for Margaret McGarvey, born March 2, 1907.

Identifies Margaret McGarvey as a daughter of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton.

View

Transcript

Margaret McGarvey, female, white, born March 2, 1907, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patton.

Why this matters

This record helps document the younger children in Isaac and Mary’s household.

Census Record

1910 United States Census, Isaac McGarvey Household

1910 United States Census for Isaac McGarvey household
1910 census page showing Isaac McGarvey’s household in Wellston, Ohio.

Documents Isaac, Mary, and several children in Wellston in 1910.

View

Transcript

Isaac McGarvey household, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Household includes Mary and children including Daniel, William, Susan, Mary Ellen, and Margaret.

Why this matters

The 1910 census confirms family continuity and shows which children remained in the household.

Death Index

Daniel McGarvey Death Index, 1914

Ohio death index entry for Daniel McGarvey
Ohio death index entry for Daniel McGarvey.

Documents Daniel McGarvey’s death in Jackson County, Ohio.

View

Transcript

McGravey, Dan. Place of death: Jackson County. Date of death: July 5, 1914.

Why this matters

This index helps account for Daniel’s short life and confirms his death date.

Census Record

1920 United States Census, Isaac McGarvey Household

1920 United States Census for Isaac McGarvey household
1920 census page showing Isaac McGarvey’s household in Wellston, Ohio.

Documents Isaac and Mary’s household after the births of their younger children.

View

Transcript

Isaac McGarvey household, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Household includes Isaac, Mary, and children including William, Charles, Margaret, and others as listed.

Why this matters

The 1920 census helps connect Isaac’s family household to Charles Leo McGarvey’s childhood.

Death Index

Mary Patton McGarvey Death Index, 1931

Ohio death index entry for Mary Patton McGarvey
Ohio death index entry for Mary McGarvey.

Documents the death of Mary Patton McGarvey, wife of Isaac McGarvey.

View

Transcript

McGarvey, Mary. Place of death: Jackson County. Date of death: May 15, 1931.

Why this matters

This record documents Mary Patton McGarvey’s death and helps close the Isaac and Mary household timeline.

Census Record

1940 United States Census, Charles McGarvey Household

1940 United States Census for Charles McGarvey household
1940 census page showing Charles McGarvey and family in Wellston, Ohio.

Shows Charles Leo McGarvey as an adult and includes Isaac McGarvey in the household context.

View

Transcript

Charles McGarvey household, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Isaac McGarvey appears in the broader household/family context.

Why this matters

This record links Isaac’s later life to Charles Leo McGarvey’s adult household.

Death Index

Isaac McGarvey Death Index, 1941

Ohio death index entry for Isaac McGarvey
Ohio death index entry for Isaac McGarvey.

Documents Isaac McGarvey’s death in 1941.

View

Transcript

McGarvey, Isaac. Date of death: May 14, 1941.

Why this matters

This record provides the closing date for Isaac McGarvey’s life timeline.

Photograph

Isaac McGarvey Portrait Photograph

Photograph of Isaac McGarvey standing outdoors wearing a hat
Isaac McGarvey standing outdoors in a family photograph, likely taken in Wellston, Ohio.

This photograph provides a rare visual record of Isaac McGarvey in later life.

View

Description

The image shows Isaac McGarvey standing outdoors, wearing a hat, light-colored shirt, and dark trousers. A house and trees appear in the background, suggesting a residential setting.

Why this matters

Photographs provide important visual context that complements documentary records, helping to humanize the historical narrative and connect the individual to place and time.

Photograph

Isaac McGarvey with Granddaughter Susan Ehrenfeld

Isaac McGarvey standing with a young girl, likely his granddaughter Susan Ehrenfeld
Isaac McGarvey standing with a young girl, most likely his granddaughter Susan Ehrenfeld, in a residential setting.

This photograph captures Isaac McGarvey in later life with a young family member, most likely his granddaughter Susan Ehrenfeld.

View

Description

The image shows Isaac McGarvey standing outdoors beside a young girl. They appear on a grassy area near a sidewalk, with houses, trees, and a street visible in the background, suggesting a small-town residential setting, likely in Ohio. Isaac wears a brimmed hat, light shirt, and dark trousers, consistent with working-class dress of the 1930s. The girl wears a short-sleeved dress typical of a child of that period.

Historical Interpretation

Based on Isaac McGarvey’s birth year (1869) and the apparent age of the child (approximately 7 to 10 years old), this photograph most likely dates to the late 1930s or early 1940s. At that time, Isaac would have been in his late 60s to early 70s.

The child is unlikely to be his daughter Susan Anna McGarvey (born 1899), who would have been an adult by this time. Instead, the age and context strongly suggest that the girl is a later-generation family member. Based on available family records, she is most likely Susan Ehrenfeld, born about 1934 in Franklin County, Ohio.

If this identification is correct, the photograph provides a rare intergenerational image of Isaac McGarvey with his granddaughter, connecting the late nineteenth-century origins of the McGarvey family to its twentieth-century descendants. Susan Ehrenfeld’s short life (c. 1934–1956) adds additional significance to the image, preserving a visual record of her childhood within the family.

Photograph

Mary Patton McGarvey with Daughter Susan Anna McGarvey

Mary Patton McGarvey standing with a young woman, likely her daughter Susan Anna McGarvey
Mary Patton McGarvey standing with a young woman, most likely her daughter Susan Anna McGarvey, outside a family home.

This photograph likely shows Mary Patton McGarvey with her daughter Susan Anna McGarvey in a domestic setting.

View

Description

The image shows two women standing beside a wood-sided house. The older woman, likely Mary Patton McGarvey, stands with her arm around a younger woman. Both wear light-colored dresses typical of everyday wear in the early twentieth century. The setting appears to be a yard adjacent to a home, suggesting a family residence.

Historical Interpretation

Mary Patton McGarvey was born in 1873. Based on her appearance in the photograph, she appears to be in her late 40s to early 50s. This would place the photograph roughly in the early to mid-1920s.

The younger woman appears to be in her late teens or early twenties. Susan Anna McGarvey, born in 1899, would have been approximately 20 to 25 years old during this same period. The age alignment strongly supports the identification of the younger woman as Susan Anna McGarvey.

The clothing also supports this timeframe. The simple, calf-length dresses and modest styling are consistent with rural or working-class fashion of the 1920s. The absence of later 1930s styling elements further supports an earlier date.

This photograph provides an important visual connection between Mary Patton McGarvey and her adult daughter, illustrating the continuity of the household across generations. Unlike later images of Isaac with a much younger child, this image clearly reflects a mother-daughter relationship within the same generation.

Marriage Record

Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton Marriage Record, 1888

1888 marriage record for Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton in Lawrence County, Ohio
Marriage record for Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton, Lawrence County, Ohio, December 1888.

Documents the marriage of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton in Lawrence County, Ohio.

View

Transcript

Parties: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton.

License: Issued the 21st day of December, A.D. 1888, to the above named parties.

Returned and filed: 26th day of December, 1888.

Marriage affidavit: The State of Ohio, Lawrence County. Before me, Lot Davis, Judge of the Court of Probate for said County, personally came Hamilton McGarvey, who being first duly sworn, saith that Isaac McGarvey is more than 18 years of age, that he has no wife living, that he is not nearer of kin to Mary Patton than second cousins, that she is more than [blank] years of age, that she has no husband living, that she resides at the present time in this county, and that there is no legal impediment to their being joined in marriage.

Consent statement: He further saith that he is the father of Isaac McGarvey and gives his consent to this marriage, and that the written consent of the mother of Mary Patton is on file in this office.

Signed: Hamilton X McGarvey, his mark.

Sworn and subscribed: before me the 21st day of December, A.D. 1888. Lot Davis, Probate Judge. Fred A. Ross, Deputy.

Marriage return: I do hereby certify, that on the 23rd day of December, A.D. 1888, by virtue of a license from the Court of Probate for said County, I joined in marriage Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton. Given under my hand the 23rd day of December, A.D. 1888. D. R. Edwards, J.P.

Historical Interpretation

This marriage record is important because it places three generations into one legal document: Hamilton McGarvey, his son Isaac McGarvey, and Isaac’s bride, Mary Patton. Hamilton appears as the sworn informant and gives consent for Isaac’s marriage, signing with his mark. The record states that Isaac was “more than 18 years of age,” which indicates he was old enough to marry with parental consent but may still have been treated as under full independent legal age in the marriage process. Based on Isaac’s later tombstone year of birth, 1869, he would have been about 19 years old at the time of the December 1888 marriage.

The record also shows that Mary Patton’s mother provided written consent, which was kept on file in the probate office. Mary’s later tombstone gives her birth year as 1873, which would make her about 15 years old at the time of the marriage. That helps explain why the record specifically references her mother’s written consent rather than simply recording Mary as an independent adult party to the marriage. The document therefore does more than record a wedding date. It also shows family consent, legal procedure, kinship safeguards, and the young ages of both Isaac and Mary at the beginning of their household.

Birth Record

Clarence McGarvey Birth Record, 1890

Birth record for Clarence McGarvey
Birth record documenting Clarence McGarvey, born July 7, 1890, in Lawrence County, Ohio.

Person: Clarence McGarvey

Record type: Birth record

Date: July 7, 1890

Place: Lawrence County, Ohio

Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton

View

Transcript

Clarence McGarvey, male, born July 7, 1890. Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton.

Why this matters

This record helps establish Isaac and Mary’s early family timeline and documents Clarence’s parentage.

Birth Index

William “Beezer” McGarvey Birth Index, 1896

Birth index for William Beezer McGarvey
Birth index documenting William McGarvey, born October 28, 1896.

Person: William “Beezer” McGarvey

Record type: Birth index

Date: October 28, 1896

Place: Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton

View

Transcript

William McGarvey, male, white, born October 28, 1896, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patton.

Why this matters

This birth index confirms William’s birth date, birthplace, and parentage.

Death Record

Clarence McGarvey Death Record, 1899

Death record for Clarence McGarvey in Jackson County, Ohio
Death record documenting Clarence McGarvey’s death in Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio.

Person: Clarence McGarvey

Record type: Death record

Date: February 26, 1899

Place: Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Age: 8 years, 7 months, 16 days

View

Transcript

Clarence McGarvey. Date of death: February 26, 1899. Age: 8 years, 7 months, 16 days. Place of death: Wellston.

Why this matters

This record explains why Clarence appears in the early family timeline but not in later census records.

Birth Index

Susan Anna McGarvey Birth Index, 1899

Birth index for Susan Anna McGarvey
Birth index documenting Susan McGarvey, born November 2, 1899.

Person: Susan Anna McGarvey

Record type: Birth index

Date: November 2, 1899

Place: Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton

View

Transcript

Susan McGarvey, female, white, born November 2, 1899, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Jap/Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patten.

Why this matters

This birth index confirms Susan Anna’s parentage while preserving the variant father-name reading in the index.

Birth Index

Mary Ellen McGarvey Birth Index, 1903

Birth index for Mary Ellen McGarvey
Birth index documenting Mary Ellen McGarvey, born February 6, 1903.

Person: Mary Ellen McGarvey

Record type: Birth index

Date: February 6, 1903

Place: Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton

View

Transcript

Mary Ellen McGarvey, female, white, born February 6, 1903, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patton.

Why this matters

Mary Ellen’s birth index extends Isaac and Mary’s documented child timeline into the early twentieth century.

Birth Index

Margaret McGarvey Birth Index, 1907

Birth index for Margaret McGarvey
Birth index documenting Margaret McGarvey, born March 2, 1907.

Person: Margaret McGarvey

Record type: Birth index

Date: March 2, 1907

Place: Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton

View

Transcript

Margaret McGarvey, female, white, born March 2, 1907, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Isaac McGarvey. Mother: Mary Patton.

Why this matters

Margaret’s birth index helps document one of Isaac and Mary’s younger children.

Local History Photograph

Clutts Building and Melvin Tilley Hardware Store, 1915

Clutts Building and Melvin Tilley Hardware Store in Wellston, Ohio, 1915
The Clutts Building on Second Street in Wellston, Ohio, with Melvin Tilley Hardware Store below and Elks Hall above, c. 1915.

Place: Second Street, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Record type: Historic photograph / local history image

Date: c. 1915

Building: Clutts Building

Businesses: Melvin Tilley Hardware Store; Elks Hall above

Status: Building no longer standing

View

Description

Historic view of the Clutts Building on Second Street in Wellston, Ohio. The image shows Melvin Tilley Hardware Store on the ground floor and Elks Hall above. Streetcar tracks are visible in the roadway, placing the building within Wellston’s early twentieth-century downtown commercial district.

Later Site History

Comparison views of Second Street in Wellston, Ohio, showing the Clutts Building area across time
Comparison views of the Second Street corner in Wellston, showing the earlier downtown building, later replacement, and the site as it appeared by 2016.

This comparison image helps show how the Second Street corner changed over time. The upper view preserves the earlier streetscape with the Clutts Building still standing. The middle image shows the later commercial block that replaced or occupied the area after the original building was gone. The lower image shows the site by 2016, after major changes to the downtown corner after the building was torn down in the 1980s.

Why this matters

This image helps place Isaac McGarvey’s life within the built environment of Wellston. While Isaac’s records center on home, work, and family, photographs like this show the downtown streetscape, businesses, and civic spaces that formed the community around the McGarvey household.

Birth Certificate

Charles Leo McGarvey Birth Certificate, 1913

Birth certificate for Charles Leo McGarvey
Birth certificate documenting Charles Leo McGarvey, born July 17, 1913, in Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio.

Person: Charles Leo McGarvey

Record type: Birth certificate

Date: July 17, 1913

Place: Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton

View

Transcript

Charles Leo McGarvey, male, white, born July 17, 1913, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio. Father: Isaac McGarvey, age 41, born in Lawrence County, Ohio, occupation ice laborer. Mother: Mary Patton, age 39, born in Lawrence County, Ohio, occupation housework.

Why this matters

This birth certificate directly documents Charles Leo’s birth date, birthplace, parents, and the occupations and birthplaces of Isaac and Mary McGarvey.

Photograph

McGarvey Children, c. 1930s

Group photograph of McGarvey children
Left to right: Mary Ellen McGarvey, Susan “Sue” McGarvey, William “Beezer” McGarvey, Margaret McGarvey, and Charles Leo McGarvey, c. 1930s.

People: Mary Ellen, Susan Anna (“Sue”), William (“Beezer”), Margaret, and Charles Leo McGarvey

Record type: Family photograph

Date: c. 1930s

Place: Likely Ohio

View

Description

The photograph shows five adult siblings standing outdoors. From left to right, the individuals are identified as Mary Ellen McGarvey, Susan “Sue” McGarvey, William “Beezer” McGarvey, Margaret McGarvey, and Charles Leo McGarvey.

Historical Interpretation

The clothing and overall composition strongly suggest a 1930s date. The women’s dresses reflect common everyday styles of the period, while the men’s short-sleeved shirts and high-waisted trousers are also consistent with 1930s fashion.

The apparent ages of the individuals align well with the known birth years of Isaac McGarvey’s children: Mary Ellen (1903), Susan (1899), William (1896), Margaret (1907), and Charles Leo (1913). This places them in their 20s to 40s during the 1930s, which matches their appearance in the photograph.

Why this matters

This photograph provides a rare visual record of the McGarvey siblings as adults, linking the documented birth records and census entries to identifiable individuals. With confirmed identifications, it becomes a key reference image for comparing other family photographs.

House Photographs

503 C Street McGarvey House, Wellston, Ohio

Front view of 503 C Street McGarvey house in Wellston, Ohio
503 C Street in Wellston, Ohio, the multigenerational McGarvey family home.

Place: 503 C Street, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Record type: House photographs

Date photographed: 2004

Photographer: John McGarvey

Family connection: Associated with Isaac McGarvey, Charles Leo McGarvey, and Fred McGarvey

This house became one of Isaac McGarvey’s most important family legacies. City property records state that the home was built in 1890. Family tradition holds that Isaac McGarvey had the house built, but the earliest document currently connecting Isaac’s household to the C Street property is the 1900 United States Census.

View

Image Gallery

Satellite Map

Historical Interpretation

The 503 C Street house is a central place in the McGarvey family story. It appears to have served as a family anchor across multiple generations, beginning with Isaac McGarvey and continuing through Charles Leo McGarvey and Fred McGarvey. City property records state that the home was built in 1890, which fits the family tradition that Isaac McGarvey had the house built.

At the same time, the evidence should be stated carefully. Family lore identifies Isaac as the builder or original family owner of the home, but the earliest known document currently connecting Isaac McGarvey’s household to C Street is the 1900 United States Census. 1900 census Later records, including William McGarvey’s World War I service record, continue to connect the family to 503 W. C Street. WWI service record

These photographs, taken by John McGarvey in 2004, preserve the appearance of the house long after it had served as a McGarvey family home. The property represents continuity, ownership, and family stability from approximately the 1890s into the 1950s.

These photographs, taken by John McGarvey in 2004, preserve the appearance of the house long after it had served as a McGarvey family home. The property represents continuity, ownership, and family stability from approximately the 1890s into the 1950s.

Tombstone

Daniel McGarvey Grave Marker

Grave marker for Daniel McGarvey, 1893 to 1914
Grave marker for Daniel McGarvey, 1893 to 1914, Ridgewood Cemetery, Wellston, Ohio.

Person: Daniel McGarvey

Record type: Tombstone photograph / cemetery memorial

Birth: February 1893, Ohio

Death: 1914

Burial: Ridgewood Cemetery, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Plot: West half, 2-D

Parents: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey

View

Transcript

Daniel McGarvey, 1893 to 1914.

Source Note

Find a Grave memorial for Daniel McGarvey, Memorial ID 126589159, Ridgewood Cemetery, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio.

Why this matters

This marker confirms Daniel McGarvey’s short life and connects him to the McGarvey family burial record in Wellston. It also supports the identification of Daniel as a child of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey.

Tombstone

Isaac and Mary McGarvey Grave Marker

Grave marker for Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey
Grave marker for Isaac McGarvey, 1869 to 1941, and Mary Patton McGarvey, 1873 to 1931.

People: Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey

Record type: Tombstone photograph

Burial place: Ridgewood Cemetery, Wellston, Jackson County, Ohio

Inscription: Isaac, 1869 to 1941; Mary, 1873 to 1931

View

Transcript

McGarvey. Isaac, 1869 to 1941. Mary, 1873 to 1931.

Why this matters

This marker visually closes the shared life story of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey, linking their marriage, household, children, and burial in Wellston.

Sources

Bibliography

  1. 1900 United States census, Isaac McGarvey household, Ohio. Digital image or database entry.
  2. 1910 United States census, Isaac McGarvey household, Ohio. Digital image or database entry.
  3. Ohio vital records, birth and death entries for the children of Isaac McGarvey and Mary Patton McGarvey.
  4. McGarvey, John. “Charles Leo McGarvey.” McGarvey Family History Project.